What is Open Manufacturing?

February 27, 2017 in Freedom to innovate, Freedom to learn by Balthas

CNC Torch from Global Village Construction Set, one of the pioneers of "open manufacturing"

CNC Torch from Global Village Construction Set, one of the pioneers of “open manufacturing” / Copyright: Cantinarivolta, licensed under CC attribution share alike

What is “open manufacturing”? When I tried to look up the term in Wikipedia some months ago, I was surprised to find no entry on “open manufacturing”.  Nice opportunity to learn more about the term by writing the first stub with a group of people discussing the issue of “open manufacturing”…

Now its your turn: Help wikipedia explain the term! The current version of the article surely needs more editing, more examples, better references, more links etc. Here is the article:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Open_manufacturing . You may also read the current version of the article as an embedded text below:

Current version of the wikipedia entry on “open manufacturing” as an embedded text :

Open Manufacturing –  as in Wikipedia:

Open Manufacturing or "Open Production" or "Design Global, Manufacture Local" is a new model of socioeconomic production in which physical objects are produced in an open, collaborative and distributed manner[1][2] and based on open design and open source principles.

Open manufacturing combines the following elements of a production process: new open production tools and methods (such as 3D printers), new value-based movements (such as the maker movement), new institutions and networks for manufacturing and production (such as FabLabs), and open source methods, software and protocols.[3][4]

Open manufacturing may also include digital modeling and fabrication and computer numeric control (CNC) of the machines used for production through open source software and open source hardware.

The philosophy of open manufacturing is close to the open-source movement, but aims at the development of physical products rather than software.[5] The term is linked to the notion of democratizing technology[6] as embodied in the Maker culture, the DIY ethic, the open source appropriate technology movement, the Fablab-network and other rooms for grassroot innovation such as hackerspaces.

According to scholar Michel Bauwens, Open Manufacturing is "the expansion of peer production to the world of physical production".[1]

Redlich and Bruns define "Open Production" as "a new form of coordination for production systems that implies a superior broker system coordinating the information and material flows between the stakeholders of production", and which will encompass the entire value creation process for physical goods: development, manufacturing, sales, support etc.[7]

A policy paper commissioned by the European Commission uses the term "maker manufacturing" and positions it between social innovation, open source ICT and manufacturing.[3]

Principles

The Openness of "open manufacturing" may relate to the nature of the product (open design), to the nature of the production machines and methods (e.g. open source 3D-printers, open source CNC), to the process of production and innovation (commons-based peer production / collaborative / distributed manufacturing), or to new forms of value creation (network-based bottom-up or hybrid versus business-centric top down).[8] Jeremy Rifkin argues, that open production through 3D-printing "will eventually and inevitably reduce marginal costs to near zero, eliminate profit, and make property exchange in markets unnecessary for many (though not all) products".[9]

Socioeconomic implications

The following points are seen as key implications of open manufacturing:[6]

  • a democratization of (the means of) production,
  • a decentralization of production and local value creation (global cooperation – local manufacturing),
  • the possibility to produce high quality prototypes and products in small quantities at moderate (to increasingly low) prices,
  • the closing of the gap between the formal and informal sector and opportunities for bottom-up open innovation, and
  • a transition from consumer to producer for manufactured goods.

In the context of socioeconomic development, open manufacturing has been described as a path towards a more sustainable industrialization on a global scale, that promotes "social sustainability" and provides the opportunity to shift to a "collaboration-oriented industrialization driven by stakeholders from countries with different development status connected in a global value creation at eye level".[10]

For developing countries, open production could notably lead to products more adapted to local problems and local markets and reduce dependencies on foreign goods, as vital products could be manufactured locally.[11] In such a context, open manufacturing is strongly linked to the broader concept of Open Source Appropriate Technology movement.

Criticism

A number of factors are seen to hamper the broad-based application of the model of "open manufacturing" and / or to realize its positive implications for more sustainable global production pattern.

The first factor is the sustainability of commons-based peer production models: "Empowerment happens only, if the participants are willing to share their knowledge with their colleagues. The participation of the actors cannot be guaranteed, thus there are many cases known, where participation could only be insufficiently realized".[10] Other problems include missing or inadequate systems of quality control, the persistent paradigm of high-volume manufacturing and its cost-efficiency, the lack of widely adopted platforms to share hardware designs, as well as challenges linked to the joint-ownership paradigm behind the open licences of open manufacturing and the fact, that hardware is much more difficult to share and to standardize than e.g. software.[6]

In developing countries, a number of factors need to be considered in addition to the points above. Scholar Waldman-Brown names the following: lack of manufacturing expertise and informality of current SMMs in emerging markets as an obstacle to quality control for final products and raw material as well as universities and vocational training programs not apt to react rapidly enough to provide the necessary knowledge and qualifications.[6]

Examples

References

  1. ^ a b Michel Bauwens: The Emergence of Open Design and Open Manufacturing. In: We_magazine Volume 02
  2. ^ Kostakis, Vasilis; Latoufis, Kostas; Liarokapis, Minas; Bauwens, Michel. "The convergence of digital commons with local manufacturing from a degrowth perspective: Two illustrative cases". Journal of Cleaner Production. doi:10.1016/j.jclepro.2016.09.077. 
  3. ^ a b Ramsden, P. Making Good our Future: Exploring the New Boundaries of Open & Social Innovation in Manufacturing. http://uk.ukwon.eu/File%20Storage/4970285_7_SIE-Making-Good-our-Future-May-2015.pdf: Policy paper for the European Commission. p. 5. 
  4. ^ Kostakis, Vasilis; Niaros, Vasilis; Dafermos, George; Bauwens, Michel. "Design global, manufacture local: Exploring the contours of an emerging productive model". Futures. doi:10.1016/j.futures.2015.09.001. 
  5. ^ "Open collaborative design". AdCiv. 2010-07-29. Retrieved 2016-11-30. 
  6. ^ a b c d Anna Waldman Brown: Exploring the Maker-Industrial Revolution: Will the Future of Production be local? BRIE Working Paper 2016-07. Online: [1]
  7. ^ Redlich, T.; Bruhns, F.-L.: Open Production - a new broker-based approach to interactive value creation and user manufacturing. In: 2008 Proceedings of the ASME International Mechanical Engineering Congress and Exposition (IMECE) Vol. 4, Design and Manufacturing, ISBN 9780791848654, pp. 181-189 [2]
  8. ^ Dickel, Sascha, Ferdinand, Jan-Peter, Petschow, Ulrich: The Multiple Applications of 3D Printing: Between Maker Movements and the Future of Manufacturing. In: Ferdinand, Jan-Peter, Petschow, Ulrich, Dickel, Sascha (2016): The Decentralized and Networked Future of Value Creation. 3D Printing and its Implications for Society, Industry, and Sustainable Development, page 12.
  9. ^ Rifkin, J. (2014). The Zero Marginal Cost Society: The Internet of Things, the Collaborative Commons, and the Eclipse of Capitalism. 
  10. ^ a b S. Basmer; S. Buxbaum-Conradi; P. Krenz; T. Redlich; J. P. Wulfsberg; F.-L. Bruhns (2015): Open Production: Chances for Social Sustainability in Manufacturing. Page 50 Online at:http://ac.els-cdn.com/S2212827114009159/1-s2.0-S2212827114009159-main.pdf?_tid=3d0c576e-b71a-11e6-9389-00000aab0f6b&acdnat=1480523580_ed36ad5c40d2a496eccdaf40697b74d2
  11. ^ Ramalingam, B.; Hernandez, K.; Prieto Martin, P. and Faith, B. (2016) Ten Frontier Technologies for International Development. Brighton: IDS. Page 43. Online: [3]

External links

source: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Open_manufacturing